This eye shadow also came from my ipsy bag in September. I have used NYX before and have been happy with the products. Their line of make up is way more affordable than most. I would say this eye trio is just ok. The colors aren't very pigmented so it takes me a little longer to get the color I'm looking for. The lightest color is pretty much non existent. Knowing that NYX isn't an expensive line I would say this is a decent trio for the money. You can get away with good looking natural eyes or darken it up with the black for a smokier effect. I think NYX is great for their lip and eyeliners. This is my first time trying their eye make up. I will stick to buying liners from this brand that are really great and super inexpensive.